Poor

Fair

Good

Very Good

Superior

I.

BASIC IDEA OF PRESENTATION

Relationship of Presentation to Best Solution

1

2

3

4

5

Measures whether the presentation actually presents the Best Solution

Completeness of Presentation

1 -  2

3  -  4

5  -  6

7  -  8

9  -  10

Measures whether the presentation provides the audience with a complete picture of solution.

Humaneness

1

2

3

4

5

Measures the productive, positive, growth potential of the solution as presented.  A score of 3 is neutral.

II.

PRESENTATION

Appropriate Use of Space

1

2

3

4

5

Measures the use of the area provided to the team for the presentation.  Use of space in an imaginative way receives higher ratings.

Communication of Ideas (Verbal/Nonverbal)

1  -  2

3  -  4

5  -  6

7  -  8

9  -  10

Measures the verbal and nonverbal presentation of ideas, including the effective use of materials (props), dialogue, and nonverbal means (gestures, use of body) to convey the solution of the team.

Creativity of Presentation

1  -  2

3  -  4

5  -  6

7  -  8

9  -  10

Measures the total creativity of the presentation in relation to other teams in the division.

Involvement of Participants

1

2

3

4

5

Measures the use of all team members in an effective manner during the presentation. 

III.

OVERALL

Persuasiveness of Presentation

1

2

3

4

5

Measures the total persuasive effect of the presentation in relation to others in the division.